How Economies Graduate

Executive Summary and Outline

Executive Summary

The transition from "Emerging Market" (EM) to "Developed Market" (DM) status is the rarest and most difficult economic migration in the global financial system. While the World Bank classifies economies purely by income, the "graduation" sought by global capital allocators requires a more profound transformation: the maturation of market accessibility, the deepening of financial systems, and the complexity of industrial output.

This report argues that true graduation requires the synchronization of four distinct developmental lenses: Income, Market Accessibility, Institutional Quality, and Financial Depth. We identify a structural framework of six pillars necessary for graduation and analyze the "Sequence Problem" that causes many aspiring graduates to stumble. Through detailed case studies of South Korea, Singapore, Poland, the Czech Republic, and Chile, alongside a critical examination of South Africa’s stalling trajectory, we isolate the specific structural factors that separate the graduates from the rest.

Detailed Outline

1. Introduction: The Exclusive Club

2. The rarity of graduation in the post-war era.

3. Distinguishing "Getting Rich" (High Income) from "Growing Up" (Developed Status).

4. The structural premium of graduation: Cost of capital and currency stability.

5. Defining the Destination: The Four Lenses of Graduation

6. The Income Lens: World Bank GNI thresholds, the "Atlas Method," and the trap of wealth without depth.

7. The Market Lens: The gatekeepers (MSCI, FTSE Russell). Accessibility, liquidity, and the "investability" criterion.

8. The Institutional Lens: The invisible infrastructure. Rule of law, contract enforcement, and the predictability of state power.

9. The Financial Lens: Depth, "Original Sin," and the capacity to absorb capital flow volatility.

10. The Graduation Framework: Six Pillars of Structural Transformation

11. Pillar 1: Economic Complexity. Moving from factor accumulation to factor productivity. The Hausmann/Hidalgo Product Space.

12. Pillar 2: The Human Capital Threshold. The education-industrialization feedback loop.

13. Pillar 3: Institutional Anchoring. The role of external constraints (OECD, EU) in locking in reforms.

14. Pillar 4: Financial Deepening. Building domestic savings pools to counter foreign volatility.

15. Pillar 5: State Capacity & Infrastructure. The physical backbone of development.

16. Pillar 6: Export Discipline. The role of global competition in forcing productivity gains.

17. The "Sequence Problem": Why Liberalization Often Fails

18. The McKinnon-Shaw hypothesis vs. reality.

19. The danger of opening the Capital Account before the Current Account.

20. Case Analysis: The Asian Financial Crisis (1997) as a sequencing failure. The role of the Bangkok International Banking Facility (BIBF).

21. Case Studies in Graduation

22. South Korea: The "Gold Standard" of industrial policy. The Heavy and Chemical Industry (HCI) drive and the lingering "Korea Discount."

23. Singapore: The FDI-Human Capital Nexus. From import substitution to global hub.

24. Poland & The Czech Republic: The "Convergence Machines." EU Accession as the ultimate institutional anchor and German supply chain integration.

25. Chile: The "Resource Ceiling." High income, high institutions, but low complexity. The reasons for its stalled MSCI status.

26. What Separates Graduates from Non-Graduates?

27. The Middle-Income Trap mechanics.

28. Premature Deindustrialization (Rodrik’s paradox).

29. The "Complexity Trap" vs. The "Institution Trap."

30. The Stalled Graduate: Application to South Africa

31. A case of "Development in Reverse."

32. The divergence between first-world finance and third-world state capacity.

33. The impact of FATF Greylisting and the logistics crisis on potential graduation.

34. The inflation targeting success vs. real economy failure.

35. Implications for Investors: The "Graduation Trade"

36. Yield compression dynamics during upgrade cycles (Poland 2018 case).

37. Currency volatility profiles: EM vs. DM behavior during stress.

38. Passive flow implications and the "Event Study" of index rebalancing.

39. Conclusion

40. The narrow path forward.

41. Final synthesis of the structural requirements for graduation.

1. Introduction: The Exclusive Club

In the lexicon of global finance, the transition from an "Emerging Market" to a "Developed Market" is perhaps the most difficult migration an economy can undertake. Since the binary classification of markets began to solidify in the late 1980s, only a handful of nations—most notably South Korea, Taiwan, Israel, Singapore, and Poland—have successfully navigated the treacherous waters between the promise of high growth and the stability of advanced status. The vast majority of nations that reach middle-income status stall, falling victim to the "Middle-Income Trap," where they become too expensive to compete with low-wage economies but remain too technologically unsophisticated to compete with advanced innovators.¹

For the serious investor and the macroeconomist, understanding this graduation process is not merely an academic exercise; it is the key to identifying long-term structural alpha. Economies that graduate undergo a fundamental rerating. Their sovereign risk premia compress, their currencies stabilize and often become reserve assets, and their equity markets attract the massive, sticky pools of capital held by global pension funds and insurers that are often mandated to hold only "developed" assets.³

However, "graduation" is a contested concept. A country can be wealthy but not developed. The World Bank may classify a high-income oil exporter as "High Income," yet MSCI and FTSE Russell may leave it in the "Emerging" or even "Frontier" bucket due to a lack of market accessibility or institutional recourse.⁵ This report posits that true economic graduation is not a singular event but a structural metamorphosis that requires the synchronization of four distinct developmental lenses: rising income, market accessibility, institutional fortitude, and financial depth.

The central thesis of this report is that graduation is not an automatic consequence of time or compound interest. It is a deliberate, policy-induced structural transformation that solves the "complexity problem" (what the country makes) and the "institutional problem" (how the country is governed).

2. Defining the Destination: The Four Lenses of Graduation

To understand how economies graduate, we must first rigorously define the destination. "Developed" is a protean term, defined differently by multilateral institutions and index providers. We categorize these definitions into four lenses.

2.1 The Income Lens: The Wealth Threshold

The most basic, yet most deceptive, metric is Gross National Income (GNI) per capita. The World Bank updates these thresholds annually using the "Atlas Method" to smooth exchange rate volatility. As of the 2026 fiscal year, the World Bank defines a "High-Income" economy as one with a GNI per capita above $13,935.⁷

The Trap of Wealth without Depth:

Reaching this threshold is necessary but insufficient for true graduation. Several Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) states and small island nations have GNI per capita figures rivaling the United States but remain classified as Emerging or Frontier Markets. This highlights a critical distinction: Wealth measures the past accumulation of resources; Development measures the sustainable capacity to generate future value.

The World Bank’s classification is purely statistical. It does not judge the quality of the economy, the diversification of exports, or the resilience of institutions. Consequently, a country can be "High Income" due to a temporary oil boom, only to fall back when prices crash. This volatility is characteristic of non-graduates. True graduates tend to maintain high-income status through economic diversification.⁶

Graduation Requirement:

To be considered for developed status by MSCI, a country typically must exceed the World Bank High Income threshold by 25% for three consecutive years.9 This "buffer" ensures that the graduation is structural, not cyclical.

2.2 The Market Lens: Accessibility and Liquidity

For the global allocator, a market is only "developed" if it is accessible. This is the primary gatekeeper used by index providers like MSCI and FTSE Russell. These institutions represent the "views and practices of the international investment community".⁵ Their classification determines the flow of trillions of dollars in passive and active funds.

Key Criteria for Market Graduation:

1. Openness to Foreign Ownership: Can foreign investors own 100% of a company? Are there "foreign ownership limits" (FOLs)? Developed markets generally have no such restrictions.

2. Currency Convertibility: Is the currency fully convertible offshore? Can an investor trade the currency 24/7? This is often the stumbling block for advanced economies like South Korea, which restricts offshore trading of the Won.¹⁰

3. Operational Efficiency: Is there a functioning omnibus account structure? Is the settlement cycle (T+1 or T+2) reliable and free of "pre-funding" requirements? Pre-funding (requiring cash in the account before a trade is executed) is a hallmark of Emerging and Frontier markets and is a major barrier to Developed status.¹⁰

4. Short Selling and Stock Lending: A developed market must allow for the efficient hedging of risk. Bans on short selling or the absence of a securities lending market are disqualifiers.⁵

Table 1: The Matrix of Market Classification

Criteria	Frontier Market (FM)	Emerging Market (EM)	Developed Market (DM)
GNI per Capita	Low / Lower-Middle	Lower-Middle / Upper-Middle	High (Sustained >$13,935 + Buffer)
Market Access	Restrictive / Closed	Partially Open / Quotas	Fully Open / No Limits
FX Convertibility	Restricted / Onshore only	Managed Float / Some Offshore	Fully Convertible / 24hr
Regulatory Quality	Modest / Unpredictable	Improving / Mixed	High / Independent / Predictable
Short Selling	Banned / Restricted	Restricted / Regulated	Allowed / Liquid
Clearing & Settlement	T+3 or worse / Pre-funding	T+2 / Reliable	T+1 or T+2 / DVP / No Pre-funding
Examples	Vietnam, Nigeria, Kenya	China, Brazil, South Africa, Chile	USA, UK, Japan, Poland

Source: Synthesized from MSCI ⁵ and FTSE Russell ³ methodologies.

2.3 The Institutional Lens: The Rule of Law

Developed markets are characterized by predictability. This lens focuses on the "rules of the game." It asks whether an investor can rely on the state to enforce contracts impartially, even against itself.

• Judicial Independence: Can a foreign investor sue the government or a state-owned enterprise (SOE) and win? In graduates, the answer is an unequivocal yes.

• Regulatory Stability: Are tax laws and capital controls subject to sudden, arbitrary changes? Institutional graduation implies that policy changes are telegraphed, consulted upon, and implemented gradually.¹¹

• Corruption: While no country is free of corruption, graduates have mechanisms that prevent corruption from becoming a tax on capital. The correlation between the World Justice Project's Rule of Law Index and Developed Market status is nearly 1:1. No country with a weak rule of law score has maintained DM status over the long term.¹³

2.4 The Financial Lens: Depth and Resilience

Finally, graduation requires a financial system that can absorb shocks rather than amplify them. This involves:

• The "Original Sin" Redemption: Emerging Markets typically suffer from "Original Sin"—the inability to issue debt in local currency to foreigners at long durations. This forces them to borrow in hard currency (USD, EUR), creating a dangerous currency mismatch on national balance sheets. Graduates like South Korea and Poland have successfully built deep local currency bond markets (LCBMs) where foreigners willingly hold local duration risk.¹⁵

• Sovereign Risk Premia: A graduate's sovereign debt trades at a spread that reflects economic fundamentals (inflation, growth) rather than existential political risk. This "spread compression" is a key signal of graduation.¹⁷

3. The Graduation Framework: Six Pillars of Structural Transformation

Why do some economies climb these ladders while others slip? Our analysis of the successful graduates (Korea, Taiwan, Singapore, Poland, Israel) suggests six structural pillars are required for graduation. These pillars must be built sequentially or simultaneously; ignoring one often leads to the "Middle-Income Trap."

Pillar 1: Economic Complexity (The Product Space)

Growth in the early stages of development is driven by factor accumulation—simply adding more labor and capital to the production process. A farmer moving to a textile factory increases productivity instantly. However, this gain is finite. Graduation requires a shift to factor productivity, which is driven by what the country produces.

This is best measured by the Economic Complexity Index (ECI) developed by Hausmann and Hidalgo.¹⁹

• The Concept: Economies graduate when they move from exporting "simple" goods (commodities, raw textiles) to "complex" goods (electronics, machinery, chemicals) that require vast networks of tacit knowledge.

• The Mechanism: Complex industries act as "schools" for the labor force. A worker in a microchip plant learns skills (quality control, systems thinking) that are transferable to other high-tech sectors. A worker in a diamond mine learns skills specific only to mining.

• The Data: South Korea’s ECI ranking skyrocketed from the 1970s to the 2010s, correlating perfectly with its graduation. Conversely, South Africa’s ECI has stagnated or declined, heavily weighted by platinum and coal, signaling a "complexity trap".²¹

• Implication: A country cannot graduate on commodities alone. It must industrialize or developing high-value services.

Pillar 2: The Human Capital Threshold

Transitioning to high-complexity industries requires a workforce capable of innovation, not just assembly.

• The Threshold: Successful graduates typically achieve universal secondary education and high tertiary enrollment rates before their rapid industrial ascent.

• The Logic: Sophisticated machinery and service economies require cognitive flexibility. The "Asian Tigers" (Korea, Taiwan, Singapore) invested heavily in education decades before they had the industries to employ those graduates. This created a surplus of human capital that attracted Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) seeking efficiency, not just cheap labor.²³

Pillar 3: Institutional Anchoring

Institutions—the legal and administrative structures—must mature to protect the accumulation of capital. For many recent graduates, this stability was imported via an external anchor.

• The EU Anchor: For Poland, the Czech Republic, and Hungary, the requirements of EU Accession forced the adoption of rigorous legal standards, competition laws, and central bank independence.²⁵ The EU acquis communautaire acted as a straightjacket that prevented institutional backsliding.

• The OECD Anchor: For countries like Chile and Korea, joining the OECD signaled a commitment to transparent data standards and peer-reviewed policy norms.²⁷

Pillar 4: Financial Deepening

A graduated economy must have a banking sector and capital market large enough to fund domestic investment without excessive reliance on volatile foreign portfolio flows.

• Metric: Private credit to GDP and stock market capitalization to GDP.

• Resilience: A deep domestic financial system acts as a spare tire. When foreign capital flees, domestic pension funds and insurers can step in to buy assets, stabilizing prices. Countries without this depth (frontier markets) see asset prices collapse completely during global risk-off events.²⁸

Pillar 5: State Capacity and Infrastructure

The physical backbone of development—ports, rail, electricity, and digital infrastructure—must be reliable.

• The Logistics Multiplier: Efficient logistics reduce the cost of trade, making exports competitive. Singapore’s obsession with port efficiency via the Maritime and Port Authority is a prime example.²⁹

• The South African Warning: Conversely, the collapse of Transnet (rail/ports) and Eskom (power) in South Africa illustrates how a failure in this pillar can decapitate an otherwise sophisticated economy.³⁰

Pillar 6: Export Discipline

Graduates almost universally adopted export-oriented industrialization (EOI) rather than import substitution industrialization (ISI).

• The Discipline Mechanism: Exporting forces domestic firms to compete with the best in the world. It provides an objective yardstick of success (global market share) that cannot be faked by lobbying domestic politicians.

• Korea's Strategy: The Korean state provided cheap credit to chaebols, but strictly conditional on export performance. If a firm failed to export, it was allowed to fail.²⁴

4. The "Sequence Problem": Why Liberalization Often Fails

A critical insight from economic history is that timing matters more than direction. The "Washington Consensus" often advocated for rapid liberalization of capital accounts. However, the "Sequence Problem" reveals that liberalizing financial flows before achieving domestic financial depth and regulatory competence leads to catastrophe.

4.1 The Theoretical Conflict: McKinnon-Shaw vs. Stiglitz

• The Liberalization View (McKinnon-Shaw): Financial repression (interest rate caps, directed credit) retards growth. Liberalizing rates and flows will allocate capital efficiently.

• The Sequencing View: Information asymmetries and weak regulation in EMs mean that rapid liberalization leads to excessive risk-taking.

• The Rule: Trade liberalization (opening the current account) should precede financial liberalization (opening the capital account). Domestic financial reforms (strengthening banks) should precede external financial liberalization.³²

4.2 The Mechanism of Failure

When an EM with a shallow financial system opens its capital account prematurely:

1. Inflow Bonanza: Global capital floods in, seeking high yields (carry trade).

2. Appreciation: The local currency strengthens, hurting export competitiveness (Dutch Disease).

3. Maturity Mismatch: Local banks borrow short-term in dollars (because it's cheap) to lend long-term in local currency (for real estate or projects).

4. Sudden Stop: A global shock occurs. Capital flees. The currency collapses. Banks with unhedged dollar liabilities become insolvent.

4.3 Case Analysis: The Asian Financial Crisis (1997) as a Sequencing Failure

Thailand in the 1990s provides the definitive lesson in failed sequencing.

• The Error: In 1993, Thailand established the Bangkok International Banking Facility (BIBF).³³ This mechanism was intended to make Bangkok a financial center rivaling Singapore. It allowed domestic banks to borrow heavily in foreign currencies.

• The Mismatch: Thai finance companies borrowed cheap short-term dollars to fund speculative, long-term real estate projects in Baht. They assumed the currency peg would hold forever.

• The Collapse: When the Baht peg broke in July 1997, the corporate and banking sectors were wiped out by the currency mismatch. The debt burden effectively doubled overnight in local currency terms.³⁵

• The Lesson: Liberalization must follow, not precede, the strengthening of prudential banking regulations and the deepening of domestic bond markets.³³

5. Case Studies in Graduation

The following case studies illustrate different paths—and impediments—to graduation.

5.1 South Korea: The Gold Standard

South Korea is the archetype of graduation, moving from a GDP per capita lower than Ghana's in the 1960s to a leading G20 economy.

• Industrial Policy (Pillar 6): The Heavy and Chemical Industry (HCI) Drive (1973-1979) was a deliberate state intervention. The government targeted six strategic industries (steel, non-ferrous metals, machinery, shipbuilding, electronics, chemicals). It directed credit to chaebols (conglomerates) conditional on export targets.²⁴ This forced firms to move up the complexity ladder.

• Education (Pillar 2): Korea achieved near-universal literacy and secondary education rapidly, creating a workforce that could absorb the technology imported during the HCI drive.

• Graduation Status:

• FTSE Russell: Promoted Korea to Developed Market in September 2009.³ This was a watershed moment, acknowledging Korea's economic size and market quality.

• MSCI: Strangely, MSCI still classifies Korea as Emerging.

• Why the Divergence? MSCI cites the lack of a 24-hour offshore currency market for the Korean Won (KRW) and rigid ID systems for foreign investors.⁵

• The "Korea Discount": Because of its lingering EM classification and corporate governance issues (chaebol dominance), Korean equities trade at significantly lower Price-to-Book (P/B) ratios than their Taiwanese or Japanese peers.
  

5.2 Singapore: The FDI Hub Model

Singapore’s graduation was driven by the Economic Development Board (EDB).²³

• Strategy: Unlike Korea, which built domestic champions, Singapore positioned itself as the most efficient base for Western Multinational Corporations (MNCs).

• Mechanism: Aggressive tax incentives, world-class infrastructure (Pillar 5), and English-language proficiency attracted high-tech manufacturing.

• Human Capital (Pillar 2): The state meticulously planned education output to match MNC needs. If the EDB attracted a petrochemical plant, the education ministry ensured polytechnics were producing chemical engineers three years later.²⁹

• Outcome: Singapore bypassed the import-substitution phase and plugged directly into the highest value-added segments of global supply chains.

5.3 Poland & The Czech Republic: The Convergence Machines

Poland and the Czech Republic represent the "Institutional Anchor" model (Pillar 3).

• The EU Anchor: EU accession (2004) provided the institutional framework that reassured investors. The adoption of EU law meant that property rights, competition policy, and state aid rules were harmonized with the West.²⁵

• Supply Chain Integration: Poland became the manufacturing engine room for Germany. It integrated into the German automotive supply chain, importing intermediate goods, adding value, and re-exporting.³⁹

• Graduation Date: FTSE Russell upgraded Poland to Developed Market status in September 2018.⁴

• Yield Compression: Following the upgrade, Polish 10-year bond yields structurally compressed, decoupling somewhat from broader EM volatility.¹⁵

5.4 Chile: The Resource Ceiling

Chile represents the "High Income Trap."

• Status: Chile has been a high-income economy and an OECD member since 2010.²⁷ It is widely considered the most stable economy in Latin America.

• The Problem: Despite high income and solid institutions, Chile remains classified as Emerging by MSCI. Why?

• Lack of Complexity (Pillar 1): The economy remains heavily dependent on copper extraction. It has failed to diversify into complex manufacturing or services to the degree of Korea or Israel.⁴²

• Liquidity (Market Lens): The equity market is relatively small and dominated by a few resource giants, limiting the "investability" required for DM status.⁴³

• Lesson: You can be rich (High Income) and well-governed (OECD), but without a deep, diverse market, you remain an Emerging Market in the eyes of global capital.

6. What Separates Graduates from Non-Graduates?

The divergence between graduates and non-graduates is rarely due to a single policy failure but rather a failure of structural adaptation.

6.1 The Middle-Income Trap Mechanics

The trap occurs when a country exhausts the gains from cheap labor and factor accumulation but fails to transition to innovation-led growth.

• Cost of Production: As wages rise, the country loses its competitive edge in low-skill manufacturing to poorer nations (e.g., Vietnam, Bangladesh).

• Capabilities Gap: Simultaneously, it lacks the advanced human capital and technology to compete with high-income nations.¹

6.2 Premature Deindustrialization

Dani Rodrik identifies a disturbing trend among non-graduates: they are deindustrializing at much lower levels of income than the West did.

• The Phenomenon: Manufacturing employment peaks at lower shares of the workforce and at lower levels of per capita income.

• The Consequence: Manufacturing has historically been the "escalator" of productivity and the engine of a middle class. Without it, developing nations are shifting directly from agriculture to low-productivity services (informal retail, security guards), bypassing the high-productivity phase.⁴⁴ This makes graduation exceptionally difficult, as services (unlike manufacturing) are harder to export and scale.

6.3 The Complexity Trap vs. The Institution Trap

• Complexity Trap: The country makes simple products and cannot coordinate the jump to complex ones because the necessary inputs (skills, infrastructure) don't exist.

• Institution Trap: The political elite extracts rents from existing industries (often resources) and blocks reforms that would allow new, competitive industries to emerge.⁴⁶ This is often the case in resource-rich non-graduates.

7. The Stalled Graduate: Application to South Africa

South Africa presents a sobering case of "development in reverse." In the 1990s, it was poised to be the African lion; today, it is a case study in premature deindustrialization and institutional decay.

7.1 Structural Regression

• Deindustrialization: South Africa has deindustrialized aggressively. Manufacturing’s share of GDP has collapsed, replaced not by high-value tradable services, but by government services and finance.

• Complexity: South Africa’s export basket has become less complex over the last 20 years, retreating to raw mineral dependence (Platinum, Coal, Iron Ore) rather than processed goods.²¹ This regression keeps it tethered to commodity cycles.

7.2 The Institutional/Financial Divergence

South Africa exhibits a unique paradox:

• Financial Lens (First World): The JSE is liquid, deep, and sophisticated. The South African Reserve Bank (SARB) is highly credible and fiercely independent, maintaining an inflation targeting framework that rivals DMs.⁴⁷ Its financial markets rank 20th globally in depth, ahead of many DMs.²⁸

• Institutional Lens (Third World): State capacity has collapsed in critical network industries.

• Logistics Crisis: Transnet (state rail/ports) has failed, costing the economy billions in lost exports. Volumes on the coal line have regressed to 1990s levels.³⁰

• Rule of Law: The FATF Greylisting in February 2023 was a watershed moment. It signaled that the country’s financial controls had degraded to the point of being a global risk for money laundering.⁴⁹ This raises the cost of capital and friction for cross-border payments.

7.3 Why South Africa Stalled

The analysis points to the middle-income trap exacerbated by a state capacity crisis. Wages in South Africa are relatively high (due to strong unions) compared to productivity, making it uncompetitive in low-end manufacturing. Yet, the education system fails to produce the skills needed for high-end services.

• Verdict: South Africa possesses the financial plumbing of a graduate but the economic engine of a struggling commodity exporter. The trajectory is currently diverging from graduation, risking a reclassification towards "Frontier" risk characteristics despite "Emerging" market size.

8. Implications for Investors: The "Graduation Trade"

For investors, identifying the next graduate is a high-reward strategy. The repricing of risk assets during the transition offers significant alpha.

8.1 Yield Compression

When a country transitions from EM to DM, its sovereign bonds undergo a structural repricing.

• Mechanism: EM bonds typically trade with a significant spread over US Treasuries to compensate for political risk and currency volatility. As graduation approaches, this spread compresses.

• Evidence: In the lead-up to Poland’s 2018 FTSE upgrade, investors saw a structural decline in yield volatility. The Polish 10-year bond increasingly correlated with German Bunds rather than Emerging Market indices.¹⁵

8.2 Currency Volatility

Graduation implies a reduction in currency volatility. Developed Market currencies (like the Polish Zloty or Korean Won) tend to act as shock absorbers.

• The Test: During global stress (e.g., COVID-19 crash), DM currencies may weaken, but the bond market usually rallies (flight to quality). In EMs, both currency and bonds often sell off simultaneously (capital flight).

• Investment Strategy: Long-term investors in graduating economies can hedge currency risk more cheaply as the "volatility risk premium" declines over time.⁵¹

8.3 Passive Flow Implications

The formal upgrade by an index provider triggers a massive "Event Study" in liquidity.

• The Flow: When FTSE upgraded Korea in 2009 and Poland in 2018, billions of dollars from passive "Developed Market" trackers (ETFs, index funds) had to buy these assets.

• The Trap: While this brings liquidity, it also means the country becomes a "small fish in a big pond." Poland is a giant in the EM index but a minnow in the DM index. This can sometimes lead to reduced active manager attention post-graduation.³

9. Conclusion: The Narrow Path

How do economies graduate? The evidence suggests that graduation is not a natural consequence of time, but the result of a deliberate, often painful, structural transformation.

It requires a "developmental state" capable of disciplining capital (as in Korea) or anchoring to a larger stable bloc (as in Poland). It requires the foresight to invest in human capital before the demand for skills exists. Most importantly, it requires the sequencing discipline to build deep domestic institutions before exposing the economy to the full force of global financial flows.

For the aspiring graduate, the lesson is clear: Wealth is not development. High commodity prices may bring wealth (as in Chile or the GCC), but only complexity and institutional depth bring graduation. For the investor, the alpha lies in distinguishing between the two—betting on the countries building complexity and institutions, and avoiding those merely riding a commodity cycle.

South Africa’s current trajectory serves as a potent warning: Institutional decay can reverse decades of financial deepening. Conversely, Poland and South Korea stand as testaments that with the right structural mix, the glass ceiling of the "Emerging Market" classification can be shattered.

Sources & Further Reading

Note on Citations: The following sources were utilized in the construction of this report. Specific data points in the text are referenced by their ID.

• Market Classification & Frameworks: MSCI Market Classification Framework ⁵; FTSE Russell Country Classification.³

• Economic Complexity & Development: Harvard Growth Lab / Hausmann (ECI) ¹⁹; Rodrik (Premature Deindustrialization).⁴⁴

• Case Studies:

• Korea: KDI/Harvard Studies on HCI Drive ²⁴; NBER on Industrial Policy ³⁷; FTSE Upgrade 2009.³⁸

• Poland: FTSE Upgrade 2018 ⁴; EU Convergence.⁵³

• Chile: OECD Membership vs. EM Status.²⁷

• South Africa: FATF Greylisting ⁴⁹; Transnet Crisis ³⁰; Growth Lab Report.⁴⁶

• Financial Sequencing: IMF/Asian Financial Crisis ³³; Sequencing of Liberalization.³²

Works cited

1. Middle-Income Trap (MIT): Review of the Conceptual Framework - Asian Development Bank, accessed January 5, 2026, https://www.adb.org/sites/default/files/publication/329201/adbi-wp760.pdf

2. Tracking the Middle-income Trap: What Is It, Who Is in It, and Why? - Levy Economics Institute of Bard College, accessed January 5, 2026, https://www.levyinstitute.org/pubs/wp_715.pdf

3. Classifying South Korea as a Developed Market - FTSE Russell Research Portal, accessed January 5, 2026, https://research.ftserussell.com/products/downloads/FTSE_South_Korea_Whitepaper_Jan2013.pdf

4. Poland is promoted to developed market status by FTSE Russell | Clifford Chance, accessed January 5, 2026, https://www.cliffordchance.com/content/dam/cliffordchance/briefings/2018/09/poland-is-promoted-to-developed-market-status-by-ftse-russell.pdf

5. Market Classification - MSCI, accessed January 5, 2026, https://www.msci.com/indexes/index-resources/market-classification

6. World Economic Outlook (WEO) - Frequently Asked Questions - International Monetary Fund, accessed January 5, 2026, https://www.imf.org/en/publications/weo/frequently-asked-questions

7. World Bank Country and Lending Groups, accessed January 5, 2026, https://datahelpdesk.worldbank.org/knowledgebase/articles/906519-world-bank-country-and-lending-groups

8. What are Emerging Markets? - Green Templeton College, accessed January 5, 2026, https://www.gtc.ox.ac.uk/academic/emerging-markets-symposium/about/what-are-emerging-markets/

9. MSCI MARKET CLASSIFICATION FRAMEWORK, accessed January 5, 2026, https://www.msci.com/documents/1296102/1330218/Market+Classification+Consultation+%28Final%29.pdf/081f2dcb-f2f5-a93b-f529-0b5aaa5847d5

10. Emerging vs. Developed Markets Classification - MSCI, accessed January 5, 2026, https://www.msci.com/documents/10199/7424d920-cdcb-462c-9e16-4c450ed70e2a

11. 2025 Global Market Accessibility Review - MSCI, accessed January 5, 2026, https://www.msci.com/downloads/web/msci-com/indexes/index-resources/market-classification/MSCI%202025%20GLOBAL%20MARKET%20ACCESSIBILITY%20REVIEW%20REPORT%20ex%20Bulgaria.pdf

12. FTSE Country Classification Process, accessed January 5, 2026, https://research.ftserussell.com/products/downloads/FTSE_Country_Classification_Paper.pdf

13. South Africa Ranks 57 out of 142 in the World Justice Project Rule of Law Index, accessed January 5, 2026, https://worldjusticeproject.org/sites/default/files/documents/South%20Africa_2.pdf

14. Rule of law by country, around the world | TheGlobalEconomy.com, accessed January 5, 2026, https://www.theglobaleconomy.com/rankings/wb_ruleoflaw/

15. The evolution of the Polish government bond market - Public Sector Economics, accessed January 5, 2026, https://www.pse-journal.hr/en/archive/the-evolution-of-the-polish-government-bond-market_6736/

16. Republic of Korea—Update - AsianBondsOnline, accessed January 5, 2026, https://asianbondsonline.adb.org/korea/market_summary/kr_market_summary_201007.pdf

17. Estimating emerging markets sovereign risk premia - Macrosynergy, accessed January 5, 2026, https://macrosynergy.com/research/estimating-emerging-markets-sovereign-risk-premia/

18. global shocks, local markets: the changing landscape of emerging market sovereign debt - International Monetary Fund, accessed January 5, 2026, https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/gfsr/2025/october/english/ch3.pdf

19. Country & Product Complexity Rankings - The Atlas of Economic Complexity, accessed January 5, 2026, https://atlas.hks.harvard.edu/rankings

20. The Atlas of Economic Complexity: Mapping Paths to Prosperity - MIT Press Direct, accessed January 5, 2026, https://direct.mit.edu/books/oa-monograph/3014/The-Atlas-of-Economic-ComplexityMapping-Paths-to

21. The Trends of The South African Economic Complexity Landscape | Journal of Public Administration and Development Alternatives, accessed January 5, 2026, https://journals.co.za/doi/10.55190/JPADA.2024.327

22. South Korea - Columbia University, accessed January 5, 2026, http://www.columbia.edu/~sk2267/eci/South%20Korea.pdf

23. III Singapore's Development Strategy in - IMF eLibrary, accessed January 5, 2026, https://www.elibrary.imf.org/display/book/9781557754639/ch003.xml

24. The Korean Heavy and Chemical Industry Drive - KDI - Korea Development Institute - RESEARCH - Reports, accessed January 5, 2026, https://www.kdi.re.kr/eng/research/reportView?pub_no=99

25. Does accession to the EU affect firms' productivity? - IZA World of Labor, accessed January 5, 2026, https://wol.iza.org/articles/does-accession-to-the-eu-affect-firms-productivity/long

26. Full article: A reluctant European? The Czech Republic's EU membership experience read through the EU Council Presidency - Taylor & Francis Online, accessed January 5, 2026, https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/14782804.2024.2348684

27. Chile in the OECD: The milestones of a decade of membership - InvestChile Blog, accessed January 5, 2026, https://blog.investchile.gob.cl/chile-in-the-oecd-the-milestones-of-a-decade-of-membership

28. South Africa's capital markets still a cut above the rest - RMB, accessed January 5, 2026, https://www.rmb.co.za/news/south-africas-capital-markets-still-a-cut-above-the-rest

29. Structural Changes and the Impact of FDI on Singapore's Manufacturing Activities, accessed January 5, 2026, https://www.eria.org/uploads/Structural-Changes-and-the-Impact-of-FDI-on-Singapore%E2%80%99s-Manufacturing-Activities.pdf

30. Transnet's Troubles: A Closer Look at South Africa's Logistics Challenges - Report Linker, accessed January 5, 2026, https://www.reportlinker.com/article/9810

31. The macrologistics effect of a state-owned enterprise, Transnet, on the South African economy, accessed January 5, 2026, https://scielo.org.za/pdf/jtscm/v17/24.pdf

32. Chapter 1 The Case for Liberalization and Some Drawbacks | Request PDF - ResearchGate, accessed January 5, 2026, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/264868820_Chapter_1_The_Case_for_Liberalization_and_Some_Drawbacks

33. Sequencing Capital Account Liberalization in: IMF Working Papers Volume 1997 Issue 157 (1997), accessed January 5, 2026, https://www.elibrary.imf.org/view/journals/001/1997/157/article-A001-en.xml

34. 1 The Asian Crisis: Causes and Consequences The Background: The crisis which hit a number of economies in Asia in 1997/98 attra - LSE, accessed January 5, 2026, https://www.lse.ac.uk/Economic-History/Assets/Documents/Workshops/Financial-Crises-Cassis/Papers/Booth.pdf

35. Lessons learnt from the Asian Financial Crisis - Bank of Thailand, accessed January 5, 2026, https://www.bot.or.th/en/our-roles/special-measures/Tom-Yum-Kung-lesson.html

36. Financial Liberalisation and the Crisis in Thailand in 1997 - VU Research Repository, accessed January 5, 2026, https://vuir.vu.edu.au/15602/1/Hansanti_2005compressed.pdf

37. South Korea's Industrial Policy: Growth with Inefficiency - NBER, accessed January 5, 2026, https://www.nber.org/digest/202111/south-koreas-industrial-policy-growth-inefficiency

38. Korea finally receives developed status from FTSE | Fund Managers - AsianInvestor, accessed January 5, 2026, https://www.asianinvestor.net/article/korea-finally-receives-developed-status-from-ftse/123118

39. The position of Czech exporters on the German market by comparison with Poland, accessed January 5, 2026, https://www.cnb.cz/en/monetary-policy/monetary-policy-reports/boxes-and-articles/The-position-of-Czech-exporters-on-the-German-market-by-comparison-with-Poland/

40. Poland promoted to Developed Market status by FTSE Russell - GPW, accessed January 5, 2026, https://www.gpw.pl/ri-press-releases?ph_main_01_start=show&cmn_id=107467&title=Poland+promoted+to+Developed+Market+status+by+FTSE+Russell

41. NBER WORKING PAPER SERIES EFFECT OF MACROPRUDENTIAL POLICIES ON SOVEREIGN BOND MARKETS, accessed January 5, 2026, https://www.nber.org/system/files/working_papers/w30477/w30477.pdf

42. Country Risk Report Chile - Allianz.com, accessed January 5, 2026, https://www.allianz.com/en/economic_research/country-and-sector-risk/country-risk/chile.html

43. Emerging Markets in Latin America Are Not Just More of the Same | MSCI, accessed January 5, 2026, https://www.msci.com/research-and-insights/blog-post/emerging-markets-in-latin-america-are-not-just-more-of-the-same

44. Full article: Premature deindustrialization: A cautionary note - Taylor & Francis, accessed January 5, 2026, https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/2329194X.2024.2397896

45. Premature Deindustrialization | NBER, accessed January 5, 2026, https://www.nber.org/papers/w20935

46. Growth Through Inclusion in South Africa, accessed January 5, 2026, https://growthlab.hks.harvard.edu/project/growth-through-inclusion-in-south-africa/

47. Macroeconomic Effects of Lowering South Africa's Inflation Target in - IMF eLibrary, accessed January 5, 2026, https://www.elibrary.imf.org/view/journals/001/2025/237/article-A001-en.xml

48. Inflation Targeting Framework - South African Reserve Bank, accessed January 5, 2026, https://www.resbank.co.za/en/home/what-we-do/monetary-policy/inflation-targeting-framework

49. South Africa has been greylisted; what are the implications for the country going forward?, accessed January 5, 2026, https://www.webberwentzel.com/News/Pages/south-africa-has-been-grey-listed-what-are-the-implications-for-the-country-going-forward.aspx

50. Economic impacts of FATF recommendations and grey-listing announcement, accessed January 5, 2026, https://econrsa.org/publications/economic-impacts-of-fatf-recommendations-and-grey-listing-announcement/

51. The Uncertain Cost of Uncertainty: An Inquiry into Exchange Rate Volatility and Bilateral Trade Flows - Harvard Kennedy School, accessed January 5, 2026, https://www.hks.harvard.edu/sites/default/files/centers/mrcbg/files/AWP_168_final.pdf

52. Premature Deindustrialization Dani Rodrik - Institute for Advanced Study, accessed January 5, 2026, https://www.ias.edu/sites/default/files/sss/pdfs/Rodrik/Research/premature-deindustrialization.pdf

Republic of Poland: Selected Issues in: IMF Staff Country Reports Volume 2025 Issue 007 (2025), accessed January 5, 2026, https://www.elibrary.imf.org/view/journals/002/2025/007/article-A001-en.xml